Nursing’s Peculiar Privilege

Dear Reader: please don’t read this blog post if you are offended by strong swear words or find talk of suicide a trigger for unsettling/risky thoughts. Kind Regards, Paul.

Who is Going Behind the Curtains?

Working over Christmas and New Year made me especially cognisant of one of the peculiar privileges that we nurses have: we spend a lot of one-to-one time with the person who is medically/surgically recovering after a suicide attempt. My current role is Consultation Liaison Mental Health Nurse – a role that provides mental health assessment, support and education in a general hospital (more info about the role here). When the person is admitted to the general hospital after a non-fatal suicide attempt we are asked to be involved in planning and providing their care.

There are few things more privileged and more important than spending time with the person who is alive after deciding not to be. I do worry that this role is sometimes delegated to the least qualified (and lowest paid) member of frontline clinical care: the Assistant In Nursing (AIN) when there is “nursing special” in place (i.e.: when there are concerns that the person may abscond and/or harm themselves again).

Naturally, being an AIN does not mean you are incapable of sensitive, compassionate, safe care. I just think that “going behind the curtains” to assist in holding and containing the often very strong emotions of the person who has survived suicide is incredibly important. I don’t feel comfortable that someone without mental health qualifications or clinical supervision is tasked with sitting at the bedside for hours at a time. It may not be good for the either the person/patient or the AIN.

Suicide rates per year. Chart courtesy of

Suicide rates per year. Chart courtesy of

Parallel Processes

In clinical supervision we often explore the parallel processes and how they apply to our clinical work. When working in perinatal mental health I aimed for the therapeutic relationship to be a template for the parent-child relationship: kind and nurturing, responsive and interactive, empowering, educative and enjoyable. The idea being that, at some level, the qualities/values that inform the therapeutic relationship can then have a knock-on effect for the relationship the parent has with their baby. Not many perinatal mental health clinicians have an abrupt, cold, clinical style of interacting with their clients: they tend to be warm, gentle communicators.

When nursing the person who has survived suicide we need to think about parallel processes again. Julie Sharrock (a rock star of consultation liaison nursing) first introduced me to the phrase “holding and containing” as a part of the therapeutic relationship. Traditionally the notion of holding and containing has been attributed as a function of the inpatient setting/building: a place to keep people safe. Julie introduced it to me as a way to keep people safe, by reframing it as a concept for interpersonal therapy. That is, we nurses can assist and model the act of holding and containing difficult emotions.

For the person who has unexpectedly found themselves alive and in hospital after intending to end life, we may need to hold and contain the person physically for a short time, but (to my way of thinking) it is even more important to support the person to hold and contain their thoughts and feelings.

Thoughts are slippery, and prone to be dropped.

Feelings are brittle, and prone to cracking.

Holding and containing such difficult-to-secure, fragile things is fraught: the clinician needs their thoughts and emotions held and contained too. Its a parallel process: as I’ve discussed previously we need to nurture the nurturers.

Suicide rates per age group (2010). Chart courtesy of

Suicide rates per age group (2010). Chart courtesy of

Profound Moments

Some of the most profound moments of my working life have occurred while supporting the person who has survived suicide.

The incredibly dark humour: “I’m such a fucking loser I can’t even kill myself properly!” said the very nice man. He was not laughing out loud, but smiling at the grim absurdity of his situation. He was alive, but physically worse-off than when he decided to die: now fractured, urinating through a tube, receiving fluids and antibiotics via an IV line. More wounds. More pain. Yet, despite the extra physical insults, he was pleased that he had survived.

The worry: “Is my brain OK? I feel really agitated and confused.” asked the lady who had been in intensive care for a few days. Her brain was OK in the long-term, the distress she was experiencing was mostly short-term stuff:  delirium is really common amongst ICU patients. Hypoxic patients aren’t so lucky: they sometimes never recover the former function of their brain.

“You are the biggest fucking cunt that has ever existed in the whole world!”, said the man after being told he was unable to leave hospital. I was filling-in paperwork that would mean he was an involuntary patient as per the Mental Health Act. I didn’t think I was being particularly nasty. The mental health act is handy because there are times when I need to say, “It seems to me that you don’t have the capacity to keep yourself safe at the moment. So,  I’ll take some of the responsibility of keeping you safe for now. Naturally, we will hand the job back to you when you come good.” Using that framework, filling-in the paperwork for the mental health act is sometimes the most nurturing thing I can do. That’s why i was genuinely surprised, not offended, when he said, “You are the biggest fucking cunt that has ever existed in the whole world!” I asked, “Really? Worse than Hitler?” He laughed and said, “Yeah, Definitely.” I laughed too. Take that Hitler.

The person who had two high perceived lethality, but fortunately non-fatal, attempts to take his life in the fortnight before we met reworded Shakespeare’s famous opening line to Hamlet. Instead of saying, “To be, or not to be, that is the question”, he said, “After what I have experienced in hospital, I now think that it is better to have a difficult life rather than no life at all.” I was so pleased to hear him think that way, and at the same time felt so sad for those people who do not have the opportunity to reconsider: those people that bypass the hospital wards and go straight to the morgue.

These are profound moments in the lives of people.

Nurses, myself included, have the peculiar privilege of being with the people who are experiencing the most important days of their life: the first few days of life that they planned not to have.

Let’s not take that peculiar privilege of nursing lightly.

In Closing

Talking and thinking about suicide can be distressing. Australians can access support via:

 Lifeline – 13 11 14

Suicide Call Back Service – 1300 659 467


phone_hotline-40Outside of Australia and not sure where to get support? Google usually displays a red telephone icon and your country’s suicide support phone number when searching for a suicide-related topic.

As always, comments and feedback on the blog post is welcome. Suicide can be a sensitive topic to comment on, and this blog is the public arena; so, before wording your comment, please check-out this: Mindframe guide

Paul McNamara, 19th January 2014

9 thoughts on “Nursing’s Peculiar Privilege

  1. angieandterry

    Wow! Beautifully beautifully (I meant there to be two beautifuls, I’m being effusive because I really liked it!) written!!
    I love the way you frame an involuntary admission for treatment.
    Also serendipitously timely – called my daughter at 0300 this a.m. after she’d had to call 000 for a suicidal friend. Such hard work for young people trying to support their not so well friends and navigate the often fraught mental health system. Any pointers for an excellent adolescent mental health service in inner city Melbourne?
    Thank you for another great piece of writing


  2. Tara Nipe

    I particularly like your discussion of involuntary admission as taking responsibility until the individual is ready to shoulder that again themselves – it’s a beautiful, empowering, positive and reassuring framework, and demonstrates your compassion and understanding. Thank you, Paul 🙂
    I agree that caring for people in pain, psychological or physical, is one of the unsung privileges of our profession – and when we’re able to do something to reduce that pain, the sense of satisfaction is great, because we’ve been able to make a real difference.


  3. Mickholloways

    Having some knowledge of those who have experienced depression and “made it to the other side” and how they felt at the time is important. How they felt like taking their own life and the feeling that this was the only solution (at the time) is important.

    I totally agree that clinical supervision is mandatory in these circumstances.


  4. Jen

    Once again Paul your eloquence is amazing.
    Like you I have felt privileged to talk to people following a suicide attempt. I also have had similar things said to me. Once I was assaulted after I explained to someone that they had to be transferred to a mental health facility to ensure their safety but this post is not about that.
    Many years ago when I was a newbie Consultation-Liaison MH Nurse, I was asked to write a short article about my role for a nursing newspaper. That was in the days before there was a Consultation Liaison Special Interest Group and I did not know any other CL nurses.
    I wrote about that when I assessed a patient I tried to make the assessment a therapeutic intervention. I also described how I tried to give them hope – hope that things could change, hope that they could feel better and hope that treatment would help them. I agree with what you said about holding and containing them and trying to help them do this for themselves.
    Re AINs, it is a pity that patients who need the most qualified staff to care for them do not always get this. I know some hospitals still manage to use trained staff for specials.


  5. Clair

    I’ve never considered seeing the ‘special’ nurse in this light. Years of ED nursing with the associated jaded burn out meant that the troublesome patients (those mentally ill or demented) were a pain in the ass, rather than a privilege. My skills were better used in the resus room, you know with the patients who were really sick. My previous attitude is shameful. I walked away from ED & in a horrid twist of fate became the mentally ill patient due to other factors. Your blog is so beautifully written. Thank you.


  6. The Fark

    As always…love ur werk….Taller than Hitler f’sure!!!
    Involuntary framework – very usable. ta muchly..


  7. Pingback: Info for 1:1 AIN/Special | meta4RN

Leave a Reply to angieandterry Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s